if somebody said Russell Brand has a psychological problem we should help him with and hope he gets over it
We absolutely should help him and hope he gets better. That doesn’t mean he shouldn’t suffer the consequences of his actions, and be kept out of society until he has done so, and ideally is judged to no longer be a threat.
I don’t get why the idea that someone should get some kind of psych treatment implies they shouldn’t also be punished. That’s a weird binary absolutism that I can’t figure out. People act like any criticism of any part of a point of view is the same as saying that POV is completely wrong and the polar opposite one is completely right. That’s just not how things work.
We absolutely should help him and hope he gets better. That doesn’t mean he shouldn’t suffer the consequences of his actions, and be kept out of society until he has done so, and ideally is judged to no longer be a threat.
I don’t get why the idea that someone should get some kind of psych treatment implies they shouldn’t also be punished. That’s a weird binary absolutism that I can’t figure out. People act like any criticism of any part of a point of view is the same as saying that POV is completely wrong and the polar opposite one is completely right. That’s just not how things work.