I don’t have very much experience on cordless tools apart from using DeWalt at home and Makita at work, both at a DIY level capacity. The 18V era is as capable as I will ever need. While trying to expand the range of tools at home though, the influx of house brands (Worksite at my local store) at very low prices became enticing. These items often advertise battery compatibility with big brands and seem sturdy enough. Wonder what everybody is using and how did you make the decision?
I’ve got Milwaukee cordless stuff, a mix between the 12v and 18v tools.
What originally got me onto Milwaukee was their M12 stubby impact wrench, it’s a nice little tool with a good amount of power behind it (quite useful for working on the bike and car). I’d been wanting a new drill and impact driver too to replace my old Makita (from their 12v nicd system) so the little impact swung the choice.
The 18v stuff came later when I wanted a proper angle grinder and a 3/4" impact (for working on some heavier machinery).
By whatever brand is available, fits your budget and has a wide enough selection of tools for your needs. It makes no difference for the vast majority of users. This is not as important decision as it might feel like. It only starts to matter if you’re a professional and you’re relying on them every day. Makita is arguably the best overall but the price reflects that as well.
I started the journey on team Makita, but their sawzall was very lackluster and I broke two cordless drills through heavy use so I switched to team Milwaukee just to test the waters and I never left.
Basically, some brands do certain tools better than the rest, and if said tool will be one of your main workhorses, I’d say that’s a pretty relevant factor. I still prefer team red’s sawzall over any other brand I’ve tried, even Hilti. Milwaukee also has a lot of specialized plumbing tools that other brands just don’t make.
In my experience,
Milwaukee has the best battery system, their tools are very good, but they are proud of their red shit and reflect it in the price. Invest if you dare, but I would not send Milwaukee as a first choice to a casual user who isn’t using them at least weekly.
DeWalt is pretty middling on tool and battery quality but theyre fine. Been through a lot of them broken at work. Has the largest support of aftermarket knockoff options though. I like dewalt for hand tools more than power tools.
Ryobi has some of the better tool selections out there- my dad still has 30+ year old Ryobi stuff kicking around from the NiCad battery days that works fine on new lithium ion batteries. Their li-ion batteries are super mid though, my dad has killed quite a few batteries that weren’t that old but just refuse to charge, even after “jump starting” them with another batt.
Makita, hilti, and others I have not had hands on experience with.
Most of the store brand stuff from Walmart, harbor freight, corner hardware stores, etc I usually avoid just because the tool selection is pretty limited and they don’t always have a real track record. I don’t want to invest in a tool, charger, and multiple batteries to have like 4 tools (drill, impact driver, a single circular saw and sometimes a vacuum lol) actually available.

Ryobi is without a doubt Hufflepuff
Missing the 5th house, Ridgid.
deleted by creator
And Black&Decker
Maybe i made a mistake but I ended up with Kobalt.
If I had not gotten into rigid when I worked at Home Depot I likely would have gone with kobalt.
I’m not sure how this hasn’t been mentioned already, but Ridgid is the only brand that offers a “lifetime” warranty on batteries.
That’s important because the tools may last for decades but the batteries certainly won’t and are often the most expensive part.
I put lifetime in quotes because there are two caveats:
- You have to buy through an official seller, i.e. home depot or directtoolsoutlet.com. No buying on amazon, eBay, or garage sales.
- You have to register the tool within 90 days or you forfeit the lifetime warranty and are left with just a 2 year warranty.
That being said, I’ve replaced half a dozen batteries under the warranty program and it’s been quick and painless (I’ve seen people who’ve had issues, so ymmv).
If you need a tool that’s not in Ridgid’s lineup you can always get a battery adapter without having to commit to a whole new battery ecosystem.
Ridgid also has a decent selection of outdoor tools too, weedeater, hedge trimmer, chainsaw, auger, etc. If yard maintainance is something important to you.
Some good advice I’ve heard is to stick with the same brand of power tools as you do for yardwork tools (assuming you’re using battery powered stuff for yardwork). The batteries are interchangeable, you don’t have to keep track of a bunch of different chargers, and new stuff often comes with more batteries.
I use the same brand for my drills and saws as I do my lawnmower, weed wacker, and leaf blower. It’s glorious.
My mower is gas but having an electric trimmer and blower that use the same batteries as the rest of my tools is amazing.

I don’t like dewalt, every company seems to buy dewalt and I’ve never liked them. They feel cheap and I’ve seen many dewalt tools break.
I like rigid because they’re made by the same company as Milwaukee and ryobi, are generally cheaper, its homedepot brand so easy to get anywhere, easy to return if they break(I’ve never broken a rigid tool).
I’m a carpenter. I use Dewalt, because the first tool I got after moving out of my parent’s house, was a dewalt drill, and I don’t want a bunch of different batteries laying around.
Truth is, it doesn’t matter which brand you use. In the end it’s mostly religion. If you don’t plan on building a house, most discount tools will work just fine for those 2 times per year you need to drill a hole, og saw a plank with a circular saw. If you’re only going to use an impact drill a few times per year, the cheap one for $20 is likely going to last you a lifetime. Don’t get caught up in branding, it’s all mostly the same, unless you’re a professional who uses the tools every single minute of every single day.
If you’re going to use it that infrequently, you’d have to make a good case for getting a battery-powered tool–there’s two more things that can go wrong or get lost.
I went with Makita way back because at that time they were the only one with a cordless router. I wanted it for working on the boat out on the mooring. Generally I’ve been super happy with them, haven’t had anything die yet. That being said I don’t use them every day, but I did use them for both work and home. I looooove the corded laminate trimmer of theirs.
I read a reddit post way back on this subject, and the person commenting was a professional in a very high end specialized shop. They said for 90% of the work they just used Ryobi tools and only for the last 10% that had to look perfect they used the super pro expensive tools. If they saw a sale on the Ryobi stuff they would stock up because they would just beat on them. Cheaper than doing that with the pro tools.
We have 2 ranges.
Milwaukee for work. - started the range many years ago and really once you have a few items it’s easier to stick with them. Main items are all 10 years old now and still have some life left. Friend has all dewalt and they seem pretty solid too. (Saws/drills/sanders/multitool)
Ryobi for around the house/garden. It’s enough for small to medium-high task. Cheaper price point and decent garden/cleaning selection. I did have a problem with one garden tool, after a year, Ryobi were very accommodating in sorting it. I also use a few third party batteries with these product, which takes price point down quite a bit.
I did pick up a Hyundai cordless lawnmower, last year. Reason bigger battery and self propelled at a cheaper price to Ryobi. They messed up the sale sent a lesser product and blamed me, had to threaten with court action to get the product I paid for. Looked to be a beast on paper but has had a few faults, and is fussy with some grass types. Given Hyundais past cust service I’ll take it as a loss.
What third party batteries do you use for your Ryobi tools? I’m looking to add a spare but want to make sure a 3rd party brand is trustworthy.
I bought mine via eBay. I have had a few over the years, I’m sure there are internet recommendations of providers but I just popped on eBay and checked reviews. Usually a different seller each time.
I have a few sizes from the 2.5 to the 5H. The 5 has a lot more juice but is an uneven weight at one end for my hedge trimmer. I favour the 3.5/4 in general. The only tool that’s fussy is the small chainsaw. It only likes a 2.5.
Mine look like the pic below but it’s irrelevant really, I suppose reviews will be the best guide. I see no difference in performance against the genuine batteries. Infact I only have one genuine left now the 2.5. I’ve had no weird noises, no power drops…some are nearing 5/6 yr old, all the light indicators still work etc. I have about 6, I did have a few more but gave them away with the lawnmower.

I have been impressed with Hercules from Harbor Freight as a DIYer. I use their 20V tools.
Fun fact: 20V tools are actually 18 volt ones. 18 volt battery is about 20 volts when fully charged. It’s purely marketing to use the max voltage because it sounds higher than the nominal voltage of 18V but it’s the same thing.
Yeah, HF really stepped up their game over the years. I can’t speak about cordless, but recently I bought three corded tools and am impressed. Really solid and powerful. ‘Will need to replace my beloved DeWalt cordless driver soon and will seriously consider HF offerings.
I haven’t used mine super heavily but so far so good, they don’t feel cheap at all
Torque Test Channel on youtube if you want some data. They have teated some cheaper brands as well.
If you wanna have more fun browse Amazon and AliExpress for adapters for other things.
Why not adapt your Dyson vacuum to use Dewalt tool batteries? There’s so many ridiculous things I’d never buy but love window shopping for.
I’ll try to answer your question. Get the cheap stuff. Once it breaks, buy the name brand.
If you don’t already have dewalt/milwaukee/makita then buy the brand that’s easiest for you to get.
For example i started with makita then moved and my local store only carries Milwaukee.
I’ve used off brand makita compatible products and they’ve worked well enough. Don’t get off brand batteries though.
If I had to start over I would be buying harbor freight brand.






