The choice between for-profit healthcare, endless wars, and financial corruption vs M4A, international rules based order, and financial regulation is the choice between having a future or not. Its existential, particularly for younger people, and they fucking know it. These motherfuckers are “leading us” straight to hell.
Progressives are not being ideologues. We feel intensely passionate about the things we stand for because we know what the consequences will be if we fail to act.
People who can’t imagine what it’s like to make informed decisions don’t understand this, so they project and assume we’re just playing some game of political campism, when that’s not what this is about at all.
Nothing is wrong with having an ideology per se, but some ideologies are better than others. A justifiable ideology should be both rational and empathetic, grounded in reality/factuality, and subject to adapt as learning occurs.
An ideology that doesn’t have those things is some combination of delusional, immoral, dogmatic, or otherwise unreasonable.
And yes, a good one should deliver good results. Know the tree by its fruits. An ideology that causes harm is a harmful ideology.
But when we talk about ‘ideologues,’ that doesn’t refer just to anyone who has an ideology. An ideologue is someone who holds an ideology without any reasonable justification. It’s usually a circular argument in which the ideology itself is its own motivation, and its own end. But ideologies aren’t ends in themselves. If it doesn’t serve a good purpose, it should be abandoned.
A person who holds an ideology with reasonable substance isn’t an ideologue, because the motivation is the purpose it serves, not dogmatic adherence.
The choice between for-profit healthcare, endless wars, and financial corruption vs M4A, international rules based order, and financial regulation is the choice between having a future or not. Its existential, particularly for younger people, and they fucking know it. These motherfuckers are “leading us” straight to hell.
Yes, this needs to be said more often.
Progressives are not being ideologues. We feel intensely passionate about the things we stand for because we know what the consequences will be if we fail to act.
People who can’t imagine what it’s like to make informed decisions don’t understand this, so they project and assume we’re just playing some game of political campism, when that’s not what this is about at all.
There’s nothing wrong with having an ideology, as long as it effectively delivers for the people.
Nothing is wrong with having an ideology per se, but some ideologies are better than others. A justifiable ideology should be both rational and empathetic, grounded in reality/factuality, and subject to adapt as learning occurs.
An ideology that doesn’t have those things is some combination of delusional, immoral, dogmatic, or otherwise unreasonable.
And yes, a good one should deliver good results. Know the tree by its fruits. An ideology that causes harm is a harmful ideology.
But when we talk about ‘ideologues,’ that doesn’t refer just to anyone who has an ideology. An ideologue is someone who holds an ideology without any reasonable justification. It’s usually a circular argument in which the ideology itself is its own motivation, and its own end. But ideologies aren’t ends in themselves. If it doesn’t serve a good purpose, it should be abandoned.
A person who holds an ideology with reasonable substance isn’t an ideologue, because the motivation is the purpose it serves, not dogmatic adherence.